top of page

Who’s Your People?

Oct 20
9 min read

La mort de mon père.1


As much as I want to, I cannot hide from the fact that today marks one year since my father died. One year since the world tilted, felt less real. I tried to make today normal, like any other, but Facebook memories and texts from well-meaning friends wouldn’t let me. 


The author and her father, circa 1980. They are riding in a pickup truck down Highway 17 in South Carolina.

My dad was such a huge part of my identity. I’ve answered, “You Wally’s daughter?” more times than I can remember, and don’t even know the times I’ve had to recite my lineage on each side of my family to answer “Who’s your people?”  My dad is the one who taught me to take pride in who I am and the South Carolina Lowcountry I am from. He taught me the history of my home and the where of my family within it. So, on this difficult day, as much as technology refused to allow me to hide from my grief, it also offered some reprieve. 


As I hid in my room, I spent hours puttering through Ancestry’s website, searching, questioning, finding. I scrolled through MyHeritage and Find-A-Grave looking for familiar names and faces. This intrusive tech was able to offer some solace after all, through a feeling of connection to loved ones I can no longer reach on my own.


Achyddiaeth2


I am not alone in this hobby of seeking out dead relatives. Genealogy has become a popular pastime for millions, especially in America. A 2022 study showed an estimated 53% of the U.S. population cannot name all four of the grandparents.3 Yet the desire to know is there. With family history growing in popularity, the genealogical question at hand has morphed from who into why. Why do we care? 


I’ve no misguided thoughts on locating a long-lost inheritance (my great-granddaddy Rawls lost the family river house in a card game) or discovering I’m next in line to a throne (though I am a great-niece of Francis Marion, which is like southern royalty). At best, I can join the DAR. 


So, with no hopes of greatness, I spend hours researching family history.  I study the Ways and Osgoods who sailed south from early Salem Village following the witch trials. I trace the Andersons who lost their lands and fled Scotland’s religious persecution. Why do any of us care what happened 100 years ago to family members? Why do we work so hard to answer “Who’s your people?” Because they brought us to our present experience.

Image of black and white photos, maps, and documents spread across a table.

As a society, our fascination with genealogy is growing at a rapid pace. AncestryDNA is over 30 million users and on average increases 5% or more annually.4  23andMe has over 13 million users. It is estimated that worldwide, over 30 million people have taken at-home ancestry DNA tests. “​​The current worldwide popularity of ancestry DNA kits stems from the universal desire to explore our family roots.”5  It gives us strings, anchorlines to people and places. People we have never met and places we have never been, yet, somehow, they begin to define our self-identity. 


It’s easy to see how this new, accessible science can easily be taken as concrete evidence to our sense of place and belonging. However, it goes against how most civilizations defined their members for thousands of years. 


Take, for example, the ways Native American tribes and nations have historically defined kinship and belonging, including through adoption and the incorporation of people from other communities. Once European settlers began putting down permanent roots, colonial governments—and later the United States government—introduced racial and bureaucratic measures to control Native lands, as well as restrict who qualifies for legal recognition, land, or other rights under government policies. As the government pushed westward, established reservations, and imposed policies that included blood-quantum requirements, the relationship between identity, ancestry, and legal recognition became increasingly complicated.6  Native nations faced growing restrictions on their ability to govern themselves and define their own citizenship, as outside authorities imposed shifting legal standards on communities that had long maintained their own systems of kinship and governance.


America the Melting Pot is a wonderful swirl of culture and creativity that blurs the definitions of our own self-identification. The term oversimplifies a problematic past that includes forced migration and forced assimilation. There was an overwhelming pressure to change names, drop accents, only use English, convert religions… the list could go on and on. While the pressure to assimilate was more overt in the past, it is still lurking about society today.


Henry Louis Gates Jr., host of the PBS series “Faces of America,” once told NPR this genealogical fascination comes from the willful amnesia that clouds many immigrants’ assimilation process.7  The human desire to “fit in” may be what drove our immigrant ancestors to forget their cultural identity. More likely, it was out of necessity to find jobs, make friends, not face prejudice. It may also be what drives us to remember today. 


There are millions of people every day who make the difficult decision to consciously leave behind home and family for safety and improved quality of life. Between 50.2 and 51.9 million Americans are immigrants from around the world, many of whom will face a new challenge—immigrant identity crisis.8 New immigrants experience a high volume of conflicted values, beliefs, and societal standards. These experiences among children and youth especially create an internal struggle between family identity and the desire to “fit in” with their surrounding peers.9


Perhaps through our genealogy we are seeking to find a clearer picture of why we are who we are. We want to know our unique combination so we can find our unique identity. This search, however, can test our views of family, home, and individuality.


Stories are emerging of people discovering their race was not at all what they were raised to believe. Verda Byrd learned at age 70 she was white. She’d been adopted as an infant in 1943 by black parents who raised her as black. She lived the black experience, married a black man, raised her children as black, attended black churches and schools.10 Should her DNA results suddenly change how she sees herself or how society sees her? 


And, what of Gail Lukasik? She was raised as white, with all white family members, only to discover that her mother, Alvera Fredic, was passing.11 Gail said, “The discovery had left me reeling, confused and in need of answers. My sense of white identity had been shattered.” 


Muintir mo rogha12


Stories like Verda and Gail’s have reinvigorated the conversation around the use of  Race and Ethnicity in our collective self-identification. The discussion is growing around how much impact either should have on how we see ourselves, how others see us, and who we call family. 


Based on faulty science,  Race is a relatively new concept from the late 18th century used to categorize humans.13  Before the 2024 revision of federal standards, the U.S. government officially only recognized five distinct races for federal reporting. This is problematic for a host of reasons. Consider immigrants or visitors from the African continent who can no longer claim their identity by their country or tribe. They are reduced to one choice on official American forms, based strictly on their physical appearance as “black.” 


Closely intertwined with the subject of Race is the social construct of Ethnicity. One’s ethnic background can encompass everything from race and language to nationality, culture and religion. This classification poses a problem for people who identify with multiple ethnicities due to their biological family ties and their chosen family connections, not to mention the influence of community and place. In a society where personal identifiers such as gender and who we consider family can be chosen, there is not a DNA test or family tree yet created to encompass our new and emerging culture. 


Our search to find home and family has led to thousands of DNA/Genealogical discoveries. People are discovering grandparents accidentally swapped at birth with strangers and learning one or both parents are not biologically related to a child. In my own small circle, a friend, born and raised a faithful southerner, discovered her birth father—who had never known she existed—living in his home state of New York. Not only did he discover a new family, but she had to reconsider her sense of homeplace. As historian Clement Eaton wrote, Southerners  are a clannish bunch who evaluate others “not so much as individuals but as belonging to a family.” Being Southern is a source of pride for many raised in the American Southeast, much as Texans are of their state and New Yorkers their city. It’s not uncommon to define yourself by where you were born and/or raised.


These familial revelations lead to finding lost loved ones and uncovering new kin. Findings have also led to household rifts, heartbreak, and lawsuits. These family surprises have become such a growing issue that the major testing companies have established helplines and resources to assist customers in navigating these stressful situations. Our collective quest for self-discovery is airing many people’s dirty laundry. 

It’s the idea of these unexpected results which has made some people question if recreational DNA testing is worth the risks. Can any amount of research or science tell us who we are? The vast majority of human DNA is nearly identical between individuals. 14


Can the .1% in our DNA that’s different truly define us? Should it? 


My own DNA results show primarily Scottish, Welsh, English, Irish, and northern European ancestry, but do poorly to reflect my family’s ties to the local Native American communities. Communities whose leaders would walk from IndianTown to Georgetown to seek my great-grandfather's advice and counsel. One where my family visited reservations and were flag bearers at pauwaus. Do I not get to claim that heritage because I inherited DNA markers that are primarily European, while other family members inherited much higher indigenous DNA?


Waŋži thiyóšpaye15


Black and white photo of Edward Anderson taken in Bucksport, South Carolina.
Black and white photo of Alice Siau

Perhaps none of this is about discovering what makes us special and sets us apart in the cultural melting pot. Maybe, for some of us, it's about finding things that make us the same. It could be about finding we’re part of one large family. 


In June of 2020, I received a message from an AncestryDNA match. It was uncovered that, between marriages, my great-grandfather had a relationship with a woman through whom he had a son, Arthur. This newfound cousin said his family knew Arthur had a white father, but older family members were reluctant to speak about a baby born out of wedlock. Arthur had been born in a time when interracial marriage was illegal and labels of judgement were given freely. By the age of five, Arthur’s mom took him to say goodbye to his birth father, as she married a black man who then “adopted” Arthur, giving him a new last name. This discovery has led to a wonderful relationship with my new cousin. 


As more people test their DNA every day, the databases grow and the percentages of ethnicity shown start to change, get more precise. There is a world of cousins out there waiting to be discovered. 

My grandfather (Arthur’s younger half-brother) always said that between his two parents, there were 20 children. 


So far, I’ve only accounted for 16.



This piece was originally written in April 2022 for the CCU MAW Creative Nonfiction course. Statistics were updated in October 2026.


REFERENCES

  1. French for "My father's death."

  2. Welsh for "Family."

  3. Ancestry Corporate. (March 2022). "New Survey from Ancestry Shows More than Half of Americans Can't Name All Four Grandparents."

  4.  AncestryDNA Learning Hub. 5 Myths About Ancestry DNA Tests. Ancestry.com. 

  5.  Larmuseau, M.H.D. Growth of ancestry DNA testing risks huge increase in paternity issues. Nat Hum Behav 3, 5 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41562-018-0499-9

  6. Native American Governance Center. "Blood Quantum and Sovereignty: A Guide."

  7. Mendelssohn, D.F. (26 Feb. 2010) Why are Americans Mad about genealogy? The New Yorker.

  8.  Batalova, Jeanne. (March 2026). "Migration Information Source: Frequently Requested Statistics on Immigrants and Immigration in the United States." Migration Policy Institute.

    • Historical Context: This number reached a peak of roughly 53.3 million in early 2025 before shifting slightly due to recent policy and enforcement changes. 

      1. Kramer, Stephanie & Passel Jeffrey S. (August 2025). What the data says about immigrants in the U.S. Pew Research Center.

  9. Multiple Sources:

    1. Barua, H., & Maheshwari, N. (2025). The interplay between migration and self-identity: a structured review using TCCM and bibliometric analysis. Frontiers in psychology, 16, 1563508. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2025.1563508

    2. Brance, K., Chatzimpyros, V., & Bentall, R. P. (2024). Social identity, mental health and the experience of migration. The British journal of social psychology, 63(4), 1681–1700. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjso.12745

    3. Armand, A. (May 2020). The Identity Crisis in France: A Study of Alienated Immigrant Populations. DigitalResearch@Fordham, Fordham University.

  10. Tan, A. (24 June 2015). Adopted Woman Raised as Black Finds Out at Age 70 That Her Birth Parents Were White. ABC News.

  11.  Lukasil, G. (20 Nov. 2017). My mother spent her life passing as white. Discovering her secret changed my view of race — and myself. The Washington Post.

  12. Irish/Scottish Gaelic phrase “People of my choice.”

  13.  Bryce, E. & Pappas, S. (9 April 2022). What’s the difference between race and ethnicity? Live Science.

  14. Herrera, J. (27 Dec. 2019). DNA Tests Can’t Tell You Your Race. Popular Science.

  15. Sioux Lakota for “One family.”

Comments


bottom of page